Reviewer Mark Richardson is confused over a supposedly “cool”, “frequently name-checked indie band” doing things that, he astutely observes, could be considered not “cool.” Shocking, I know. What’s going on in Williamsburg?
The first time through, hearing “Graze” explode into this weird sing-along RenFaire jig is a bit of a shock. It sounds very far from what we imagine a hip, frequently name-checked indie band with abrasive experimental roots to sound like. And their performance of it is certainly not tongue-in-cheek: They sound joyful, and they’re not smirking. (I’m not sure they’re capable of that particular expression, to be honest.) And thus it becomes clear that Animal Collective, despite having become a certain kind of alt touchstone in 2009, doesn’t much care about conventional notions of cool. If they want to get dorky and put in a section that asks you to bust out the medieval garb and hop around on one leg for a minute, they’ll do it. And maybe they’ll put this song in the lead spot on an EP that follows up the biggest and most successful record of their career. All this went through my mind before finding out, after reading Fall Be Kind’s credits, that the flute sample comes courtesy of an artist whose name became a punchline after an endless run of goofy TV spots advertising his music: Zamfir, the Master of the Pan Flute. Cool? These guys aren’t sweating it.
Really, they “sound joyful” and it’s “not tongue-in-cheek”? Scandalous.
